20 bands covering R.E.M.? At Carnegie Hall? What’s not to love?
First off, a note about how I figured out this show. No, every artists did not play 3 songs, they all only played one, with the exception of Patti Smith(45.66) and Calexico(40.33) (sorta). But, I did hike it up to NYC and back specifically for this show. And it is the sort of event that merits extra special consideration. So here’s the deal: each band counts as 1/3 of a band. BUT, I cannot use this band again to count against the 333. So yes, am I cutting corners to count Hootie(45.33), maybe. But I also can’t count Bob Mould(41) again, and he lives and plays often in DC. Seem fair to you? Good. One last note, this may get a little long, so I have intentionally left out band images to keep it shorter. Thanks for playing…
Carnegie Hall is one of those venues you simply don’t get a chance to see these types of shows at. So, it was amazing to be there, even if it was the nose-bleeds. The dB’s(39.33) started the night off the right way, with “Fall on Me.” In a night that was not full of what would normally be considered R.E.M.(46) singles, this was a great way to start it, and a good band to pull it off.
If you’ve never heard of Fink(39.66), don’t feel bad, neither had I. No idea how he ended up on the bill, but his mellow acoustic version of “The Apologist,” a song from Up I am also not familiar with, left no indelible marks on my memory. This was followed by Keren Ann(40) and her version of “Man on the Moon,” which is actually one of my least favorite R.E.M. songs. And yeah, I don’t know who she is either.
Calexico were the house band of the night, playing behind a lot of the solo artists. They also contributed the fairly quiet “Wendall Gee.”. Not bad, but on top of the very low key opening sequence, I was more than a little concerned. And then Rachael Yamagata(40.66) took on “The Great Beyond.” A very pretty song, but again, isn’t R.E.M. a rock band?
Thank God for Bob Mould. His version of “Sitting Still” finally cleared the decks for what had been a bit of a let down thus far. Considering this song isn’t a terribly hard rocker, for Mould to turn it into one, clearly the gloves were off when it comes to artistic interpretation. The old school love continued with the Feelies (41.33) doing “Carnival of Sorts (Box Cars).” A perfect song for the recently reunited band to cover, so much so that it seemed like it could have easily been from their own catalog.
What could be my favorite R.E.M. song, “Night Swimming,” was done reasonably well by Ingrid Michaelson(41.66) accompanied only by a cello. Not great, but I’m just happy to have heard it done live. Things finally got interesting when Glen Hansard(42) did “Hairshirt,” mandolin and all. He did a fantastic job of copying Stipe’s vocal stylings, all the way down to the warbles. The Apples in Stereo(42.33) then came in and tore it up with “So. Central Rain,” finally hitting the full pop value I had been waiting for all night. Like many of the acts before them, there was some vocal issues with the sound system, which likely comes with the territory since so many different folks were stepping to the mic. Regardless, this was a highlight.
And then the twang came back. I recognize older R.E.M. songs tend to be a little more country, but Guster(42.66) took “Shaking Through” to a new level. This would have been ok if so much of the night hadn’t been on the lighter side. Followed up by Marshall Crenshaw(43) covering “Supernatural Superserious” kind of poorly, and Rhett Miller(43.33) flat out over-doing “Driver 8″ — he really looked like he was peeing in his pants — the night was in danger of being way less than I had hoped. But happily, things changed…
Kimya Dawson(43.66) tackled “World Leader Pretend” like I could never imagine it tackled. Along with an interesting dance troupe — whose name I have sadly forgotten — and a glockenspiel, she hit it perfectly, covering one of R.E.M.’s more overtly critical songs in her own engaging yet nearly childlike style. She finished the song along with the dancers, all in costumes of bears, cops and the like, chanting the chorus. Absolutely a highlight. Perhaps the only act capable of following this was Vic Chestnutt and Elf Power(44) covering “Everybody Hurts.” There may not be a man alive better suited to sing this song with the emotional power Vic Chestnutt brings to the table. Resigned to a wheelchair since he was 18 (now 44), the Athens, GA resident knows a little about human suffering. That was a great moment.
One band I was very excited to see was Throwing Muses(44.33). I have never seen my home state band live, and given how infrequent their reunions/performances are, I wasn’t holding out hope they would come this way any time soon. Their version of “Perfect Circle” was good, but not as good as I had hoped. But this performance proved once again that R.E.M. has put out more amazing songs I’ve nearly forgotten about than most bands nowadays will ever crank out. This was followed by Dar Williams(44.66) doing a very un-Dar Williams version of “At my Most Beautiful.” Dressed in a full out gown, Dar adequately handled one of the band’s most beautiful songs (no pun intended). Not what I expected, but not terrible.
Ex-Be Good Tanya Jolie Holland(45), covered “Don’t Go Back to Rockville,” which is always a funny song for those of us living in the DC area. Or, at least I geakishly find it funny. Darius Rucker (aka Hootie), did a less than stirring version of “I Believe,” which has never been one of my favorite songs. Darius, like many of the artists performing, grew up or went to college on the East coast, making them all serious fans of R.E.M., and making their presence on stage quite apprapo.
Finally, Patti Smith came out and kinda sorta butchered “New Test Leper,” which you can more or less forgive, because she is Patti Smith. She really only forgot the lyrics, and she did recover. But she also proved to be quite a spazz. When R.E.M. came out and performed “E-bow the letter” with her — as we all expected/hoped they would — she was certainly not on top of her game either. Didn’t matter though, seeing the guys play that live with her was amazing. While I would have loved it if they stayed on stage to play a few more songs, in many ways that was a more than fitting ending.
You can obviously tell from the set list that many of the hits were absent. But with a band like R.E.M., with so much material to cover, it actually seems far more appropriate to pull from the very wide palette of material the band has, rather than focus solely on the hits. In thinking about it, R.E.M. is one of the few bands that I can actually relate more to the albums than particular songs. Document means very different things to me than say New Adventures in Hi Fi, or even Murmur. I was once friends with a guy who would lay out how R.E.M.’s catalog was the soundtrack to his life, and I can understand how we all feel that way. Even the newer material fits. Minus Bill Berry the band took some time to find their stride, arguably only doing so finally on last year’s Accelerate. Much like me and many of my college contemporaries who have finally gotten our shit together as we climb further into our 30s.
But that is almost too visceral right? R.E.M. has reached far more of us on a personal level that is much more immediate than say Elliot Smith ever could. But that doesn’t make it any less moving, or R.E.M. any less deep as a band. On the contrary, I think it is their ability to write songs than can accomplish this, something as simple as the urging of someone to not go back to Rockville, that makes them an amazing band. Because we all have a Rockville, we all have those moments in our life referenced in “Nightswimming,” and we can all certainly take something from a song like “Everybody Hurts.” These are awkwardly obvious examples, but if you take a look at bands one could consider contemporaries of R.E.M., U2 on one end, Husker Du on the other, neither of them nor anyone in between is able to approach the connection one gets to an R.E.M. song, even at their most absurd. This is why we were there to celebrate R.E.M. at Carnegie Hall, because after 25+ years of making music they are still able to find that connection in their music, and we are still able to appreciate it.